County waives its right after federal judge denies
waste firm's request to participate
A federal judge has denied a request to let the company that runs Page
County's landfill participate in next month's hearing to close the
site.
National Waste Services of Virginia, which runs Battle Creek Landfill
for the county, asked to participate in a hearing state officials called
to have the dump's permit revoked.
But U.S. District Judge James R. Spencer ruled Thursday that the
company had no standing in the matter.
The decision prompted Page County to waive its right to the hearing,
which is now canceled.
So the decision on revocation will go straight to a Department of
Environmental Quality official for a ruling, said Tim Murtaugh, spokesman
for Attorney General Jerry W. Kilgore.
Kilgore's office is representing DEQ, which claims that Battle Creek is
taking in more trash than it can handle.
State lawyers are determined to have the landfill closed, though they
realize that scenario is unlikely, Murtaugh said.
"At the very least, we will ensure that the landfill comes into
compliance. We are seeking revocation, but we're realistic about the
chances of that," Murtaugh said.
National Waste President Bart Begley did not respond to a message for
comment.
Frank Daniel, director of DEQ's Tidewater Regional Office, has been
chosen to decide on the revocation issue. Page and DEQ will submit
documentation for Daniel to review.
National Waste signed a contract with the county in 2001 to take over
operation of Battle Creek, which lost millions of dollars its first two
years in business because the county failed to attract enough trash.
Since late 2001, the dump has been criticized for taking in too much
waste. After National Waste took over, garbage intake jumped from about
200 tons per day to more than 1,000 tons, hauled in on a stream of trash
trucks that became a nuisance to some local motorists.
The DEQ believes Battle Creek can't handle that volume of trash and
issued a series of citations against the site last year before calling for
a hearing to have its permit revoked.
National Waste sought to be included in the hearing - a move Kilgore's
office fought vehemently.
Last month, the company filed a lawsuit in U.S. District Court in
Richmond to force its way into the proceeding. The firm claimed that
excluding it from the hearing would be a constitutional violation of due
process.
But Spencer disagreed, citing state law that precludes any right to
operate a dump. "NWS [National Waste] lacks a constitutionally protected
property interest in both the Permit and in the continued operation of the
Landfill," Spencer wrote.
In waiving its right to a hearing, Page is not conceding fault or
agreeing with DEQ's allegations against Battle Creek, said Jim Cornwell,
the county's lawyer.
"We just said we don't want a hearing on it, and that we'll let Daniel
make a determination," Cornwell said.
National Waste and Page County had been cooperating in the dispute with
DEQ. But the Page County Board of Supervisors changed four of five members
after November elections, and relations between the local government and
the company have become confrontational.
Last month, the county issued National Waste a notice of default that
itemizes alleged operating deficiencies at the site.
Page also voted last month to require that more trucks hauling to the
landfill pay for permits. National Waste sued the county over the decision
in a state court claim that is still pending.